Fridge.com Logo
Fridge.com | Blog

Built In Ice Maker Vs. Small Upright Freezer

Share Fridge.com:
Built In Ice Maker Vs. Small Upright Freezer | Fridge.com
Elizabeth Rodriguez
Fridge.com Editorial Team
11 min read
Oct 1, 2024(Updated Oct 16, 2025)

Built-In Ice Maker Vs. Small Upright Freezer

What's the Best Fit for You?

Deciding between a built-in ice maker and a small upright freezer boils down to what you need and how you live. Both have their perks, but they serve different purposes. Let’s break it down so you can make the best choice.

Feature Built-In Ice Maker Small Upright Freezer
Main Job Making ice Storing frozen stuff
Installation Built into your cabinets Stands alone
Space Needed Fixed spot in your kitchen Can go anywhere
Ice Output Lots of ice Not much (if any)
Storage Space Just ice Food, ice cream, etc.
Convenience Always have ice General freezing needs

A built-in ice maker is your go-to if you love hosting parties or just need a lot of ice on hand. It fits right into your kitchen cabinets, saving counter space and keeping the ice flowing. Want to know more about built-in appliances? Check out our article on built-in kegerator Vs. portable freezer.

On the flip side, a small upright freezer is a storage champ. It can hold all sorts of frozen goodies like food, ice cream, and leftovers. Perfect for families or anyone who needs extra freezer space. Plus, you can put it pretty much anywhere—garage, basement, kitchen, you name it. For more on upright freezers, see our comparison on freestanding wine cooler Vs. upright freezer.

Think about where you’ll put it. Built-in ice makers need a dedicated spot in your cabinets, while small upright freezers are more flexible. Also, consider what you’ll use it for. If you need a constant ice supply, go for the ice maker. If you need more freezer space for various items, the upright freezer is your best bet.

Energy use is another thing to think about. Built-in ice makers and small upright freezers use different amounts of energy. Checking out their energy efficiency can help you save on your utility bills and be kinder to the planet. For more on energy-efficient appliances, read our article on built-in refrigerator Vs. energy-efficient refrigerator.

In a nutshell, both built-in ice makers and small upright freezers have their own set of benefits. Knowing these can help you pick the right one for your needs.

Built-In Ice Maker

How It Works and What It Offers

A built-in ice maker is your kitchen's secret weapon for never running out of ice. Tucked neatly under your counter or inside a cabinet, it churns out ice without you lifting a finger. No more wrestling with ice trays or making late-night runs to the store for a bag of ice.

Here’s what you get with a built-in ice maker:

  • Automatic Ice Production: It keeps making ice around the clock, so you’re always ready for a party or a hot day.
  • Storage Bin: Holds the ice until you need it, with sizes varying by model.
  • Ice Types: Choose from cubed, crushed, or nugget ice to match your drink style.
  • Filtration Systems: Many models filter the water, giving you clear, clean ice.
  • User-Friendly Controls: Simple controls let you tweak the ice-making process to your liking.

Why You’ll Love a Built-In Ice Maker

Here’s why a built-in ice maker is a game-changer:

  • Convenience: Always have ice on hand without the hassle of refilling trays or buying bags.
  • Space-Saving: Fits right into your kitchen design, freeing up counter and fridge space.
  • Looks Great: Blends in with your cabinets and appliances, making your kitchen look sleek.
  • Top-Notch Ice: Produces better quality ice than portable units, with clear, tasteless cubes.
  • High Capacity: Makes and stores plenty of ice for parties or everyday use.
Feature Built-In Ice Maker
Ice Production Continuous
Storage Capacity Moderate to Large
Ice Types Cubed, Crushed, Nugget
Water Filtration Yes
Space Requirement Built-In/Under-Counter

Things to Consider

Before you jump in, here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Installation Cost: Buying and installing a built-in ice maker can be pricier than other options.
  • Space Needs: You’ll need a dedicated spot in your kitchen or bar area, which might be tricky in smaller spaces.
  • Maintenance: Regular upkeep is a must to keep it running smoothly, like cleaning the ice bin and changing water filters.
  • Energy Use: These units can use more energy than portable ones, which might bump up your energy bill.
  • Repair Costs: Fixing or replacing parts can be expensive, especially if it’s built into custom cabinetry.

Want to see how a built-in ice maker stacks up against other appliances? Check out our article on built-in kegerator Vs. portable freezer.

By knowing the ins and outs of built-in ice makers, you can decide if it’s the right fit for you. If you’re weighing other options, take a look at our comparisons like portable refrigerator Vs. wine chiller and black slate refrigerator Vs. convertible refrigerator.

Small Upright Freezer

Small upright freezers are a game-changer for anyone needing extra freezer space without sacrificing too much room. Perfect for homes, apartments, or even offices, these compact units pack a punch with their features and functionality.

Why You’ll Love It

These little wonders are designed to give you maximum storage while taking up minimal space. They usually come with adjustable shelves, door bins, and sometimes drawers, making it super easy to organize your frozen goodies. Here’s what you can expect:

  • Adjustable Shelves: Customize the space to fit anything from frozen pizzas to ice cream tubs.
  • Temperature Control: Set the perfect chill for your ice cream or veggies.
  • Frost-Free Operation: Say goodbye to manual defrosting.
  • Compact Design: Ideal for tight spaces like apartments, offices, or even your garage.

Why It’s a Smart Choice

Got a small space but need more freezer room? A small upright freezer is your best bet. Here’s why:

  • Space-Saver: Takes up less floor space than those bulky chest freezers.
  • Easy to Organize: Adjustable shelves and bins make finding your frozen peas a breeze.
  • Quick Access: Everything’s at eye level, so no more digging around.
  • Fits Anywhere: Perfect for kitchens, basements, or garages.
Feature Benefit
Compact Design Fits in small spaces
Adjustable Shelves Customizable storage
Frost-Free Operation Reduced maintenance
Temperature Control Optimal freezing conditions

Things to Keep in Mind

While these freezers are pretty awesome, they do have a few downsides:

  • Limited Space: Not as roomy as bigger freezers.
  • Energy Use: Can use more energy than chest freezers.
  • Insulation: Vertical design might not insulate as well, leading to some energy loss.
  • Noise: Some models can be a bit noisy.
Drawback Description
Limited Capacity Less storage space
Higher Energy Use More energy consumption
Less Efficient Insulation Potential energy loss
Potential Noise May be noisier

When deciding between a built-in ice maker and a small upright freezer, think about what you really need. Consider your space, how much you’ll use it, and what you’ll be storing. For more comparisons, check out our articles on freestanding wine cooler Vs. upright freezer or chest freezer Vs. deep freezer.

Things to Think About

Choosing between a built-in ice maker and a small upright freezer? Let's break it down so you can make the best choice for your needs.

Space and Placement

First up, space and where you want to put it. Built-in ice makers fit right into your kitchen cabinets or under the counter. They look sleek and don't take up much room, but you'll need a pro to install them and hook up a water line.

Small upright freezers, on the other hand, can go almost anywhere—garage, basement, pantry, you name it. They usually hold more stuff than built-in ice makers but take up more floor space.

Feature Built-In Ice Maker Small Upright Freezer
Space Needed Minimal, fits into cabinets Takes up more floor space
Installation Needs professional setup Just plug it in
Placement Options Mostly kitchen or bar area Can go in different spots

How You'll Use It

Think about how you'll use it. Built-in ice makers give you a steady stream of ice, perfect for parties or big families. They're easy to use and often have cool features like automatic ice dispensing and filters.

Small upright freezers are more flexible. They can store ice and other frozen foods, making them handy if you need extra freezer space for groceries.

Feature Built-In Ice Maker Small Upright Freezer
Ice Supply Continuous, great for parties Can store ice, but not nonstop
Extra Storage Mostly just ice Can hold various frozen items
Convenience Easy ice access Multi-purpose storage

Energy Use

Energy use is another biggie. Built-in ice makers can use more energy because they're always making ice and keeping it cold. But newer models often have energy-saving features.

Small upright freezers also use energy, but they can be more efficient depending on the model. They usually have better insulation and don't need to cycle as often to stay cold.

Feature Built-In Ice Maker Small Upright Freezer
Energy Use Higher due to constant ice making Varies, generally more efficient
Energy-Saving Features Often included in newer models Depends on the model
Temperature Control Needs constant cooling Better insulation, less cycling

So, when you're deciding between a built-in ice maker and a small upright freezer, think about your space, how you'll use it, and energy efficiency. For more comparisons, check out our articles on built-in kegerator Vs. portable freezer and beverage cooler Vs. garage freezer.

Keeping Your Appliances Running Smoothly

Taking care of your built-in ice makers and small upright freezers isn't rocket science, but it does require a bit of elbow grease. Let's break down the basics of keeping these appliances in tip-top shape.

Built-In Ice Makers: TLC Tips

Your ice maker is like a trusty sidekick, always ready to chill your drinks. But even sidekicks need some love. Here's how to keep it running smoothly:

  1. Regular Cleaning: Give your ice maker a good scrub every six months. A mix of warm water and mild detergent works wonders. Just make sure to rinse off all the soap.
  2. Descaling: Hard water can leave nasty mineral deposits inside your ice maker. Use a descaling solution (check the manual for recommendations) to keep it clean.
  3. Sanitizing: After cleaning, run a water and food-safe sanitizer solution through the system. This kills any lurking bacteria or mold.
  4. Inspecting Components: Check the water filter, ice bin, and other parts regularly. Swap out the water filter every six months, or as the manufacturer suggests.
  5. Checking for Leaks: Keep an eye out for any leaks in the water supply line. Fix them ASAP to avoid water damage and keep things running efficiently.

Small Upright Freezers: Keepin' It Cool

Your small upright freezer is a workhorse, but it needs some attention to keep things frosty. Here's what to do:

  1. Defrosting: If your freezer isn't frost-free, defrost it when ice buildup hits about 1/4 inch. Turn it off, empty it out, and let the ice melt. Mop up any water with towels.
  2. Cleaning the Interior: Use warm water and baking soda to clean the inside. This helps nix odors and keeps things fresh. Rinse and dry thoroughly.
  3. Cleaning the Coils: Dusty coils can make your freezer work harder. Clean them twice a year with a vacuum or coil brush.
  4. Checking the Door Seal: Inspect the door gasket for cracks or damage. A bad seal makes your freezer work overtime, wasting energy. Replace it if needed.
  5. Organizing the Freezer: Keep things organized to allow proper air circulation. Don't overload it, or you'll strain the compressor.
Maintenance Task How Often Built-In Ice Maker Small Upright Freezer
Cleaning Interior Every 6 months Yes Yes
Descaling Every 6 months Yes No
Sanitizing Every 6 months Yes No
Water Filter Replacement Every 6 months Yes No
Defrosting As Needed No Yes
Cleaning Coils Twice a Year No Yes
Checking Door Seal Monthly Yes Yes
Organizing Contents Monthly Yes Yes

Stick to these tips, and your built-in ice maker and small upright freezer will stay in great shape. For more cool comparisons, check out our articles on built-in kegerator Vs. portable freezer and freestanding wine cooler Vs. upright freezer.

Get Your Upgrade or New Addition at Fridge.com

Whether you're searching for your perfect fridgefreezerwine fridgebeer fridgeice maker, or kegerator, we have what you need.

Shop the world's best brands at Fridge.com.

We also have tons of awesome articles about kitchen stuff and home news. Enhance your home, garage, backyard, patio, and office with the coolest essentials. With every necessary type of residential refrigerator or freezer in our collection, we've got you covered.

Elevate your game and shop now at Fridge.com!

Share this Fridge.com article:
Built In Ice Maker Vs. Small Upright Freezer | Fridge.com Blog