Refrigerator Repair vs Replace Calculator

Should you fix it or buy a new one?

Six honest inputs. We apply the 50% rule (USDA appliance guidance), the 10-year ENERGY STAR cutoff, and a 5-year total-cost comparison — then give you a single verdict.

⏱ ~45 secENERGY STAR · DOE · AHAM · USDASpecialty
Share
Tell us about the repair
Years since manufacture
The quote you have in hand
A comparable new unit, fully delivered
From the EnergyGuide label or estimate
ENERGY STAR full-size: ~400–500
US avg per EIA: ~16.5¢
Verdict · Repair · High confidence
Repair it.

The 5-year math clearly favors repair, you're under the 10-year cutoff, and the quote is well below half of replacement. Get it fixed.

5-yr repair
$928
5-yr replace
$1,871
Energy save / yr
$41
Break-even
27.9 yr
Why this verdict
  • Repair is significantly cheaper over 5 years.

Find a service tech →
How we decide

The methodology

01

10-year ENERGY STAR rule (hard)

Refrigerators 10 years or older may use up to 35% more energy than newer ENERGY STAR certified models. Past the cutoff → replace, regardless of how cheap the repair is.

02

50% rule (USDA appliance guidance)

If a repair quote is more than half the cost of a comparable new unit, replacement is the better economic call. The verdict flips the moment the math crosses 50%.

03

5-year total-cost comparison

Repair cost + 5 yr of current-unit energy vs new cost + 5 yr of new-unit energy, both at your electricity rate. Whichever is lower wins — confidence is High when the gap is decisive.

Questions

Frequently asked

Widely cited in USDA appliance guidance: if a repair quote is more than half the cost of a new comparable unit, replacement is the better economic call. The calculator applies it for you.
Keep going

Tools that pair with this one

Next step

If it is time to replace, explore your options.

Answer five questions to explore a starting product group, with prices where available. Verify dimensions, features and warranty terms on each product page.

Start fridge match